18 Inspiring Elf on the Shelf Ideas for 2 Elves

Have you added a second elf to your annual Elf on the Shelf festivities?

If you have a new elf, I’ve got you covered with some new ideas that you haven’t seen before.

The great thing is, you can do pretty much anything with two elves that you could do with one.

My two elves almost always stay together.

It’s just easier that way.

Double the elves doesn’t mean double trouble.

Just beware, adding a second elf into the mix is just the beginning.

Soon, you’ll be adding pets, too.

But in all seriousness.

Remember not to make this too stressful.

If done the right way, it can be so much fun.

If elaborate set-ups are making you stress out, stick to a more simple idea!

Your kids will still love waking up the next morning to find their elf friends.

I like to balance some of the creative elf ideas found below with last minute elf ideas and quick ideas.

Having your elf antics be more simple, or having your elf simply find a new spot to sit each day is still special and fun.

So that I don’t burn myself out early in the season.

The best part is that little kids don’t really care.

So without further ado, let’s check out some creative ideas with this fun tradition!

This post may contain affiliate links.

Elf on the Shelf Ideas for 2 Elves

1.Have Your Elves Help Decorate

Your elves can make simple and adorable snowmen for your hallway doors.

All you need is some scissors and some black and orange construction paper or card stock.

Prop your elves somewhere nearby so that your children know the elves did it.

2.Hiding Candy Canes

Have your two elves sitting by two empty candy cane boxes.

Hide all 24 candy canes around the house for your kids to find.

This one will take a while, so it’s best to do it on the weekend or a day off of school.

3.Making Snow Angels

Your elves can make snow angels to commemorate the holiday season.

You can use flour (which is super messy, so be warned).

You could also use sprinkles or mini marshmallows instead.

4.Refrigerator Googly Eyes

Isn’t this just the cutest?

Okay, it’s definitely not for everyone.

And if you’re not into the whole “be good because the elves are watching so you can make it onto the nice list” thing, it’s still a cute idea that your kids would love.

And if your house is anything like mine, you’ve already got plenty of googly eyes laying around.

5.Rolling In A Toilet Paper Roll

This is one of the really easy ideas but it’s also such a great one.

My kids still remember this as one of their favorites from a few years ago.

Simply stuff your elves into two different toilet paper rolls (full ones) and roll them down the stairs or down the hallway.

6.Putting Up Christmas Lights

There can never be too many Christmas lights, especially in a kid’s mind.

Your elves can use this fun idea to put up more Christmas lights (even in your kids’ rooms if they are heavy sleepers).

They could even be rappelling from the lights or hanging upside down from them for more fun.

7.Bringing “Elf Yourself” Setups

One thing that my kids love doing, whenever we go somewhere, is sticking their heads in those silly cutouts.

If you have time and some big cardboard boxes (of course you do, it’s the Christmas season), you can create a couple of these amazing elf cutouts.

Then you can literally save them for other years, bring them out for parties, etc.

They will definitely be worth the effort.

8.Playing Board Games

One year, I had my elves leave out about 10 different board games that they had played throughout the night.

They were set up at the game that is my kids’ favorite.

You could of course just stick with one board game, but the more the merrier!

9.Bringing A Small Gift

It’s always fun to have the elves bring little gifts that you were going to be giving before Christmas anyway.

Your elves could bring advent calendars, gingerbread house kits, Christmas pajamas or any of my free printables:

9.Who Needs Silverware When You Can Eat Candy All Day?

Those darn elves, always messing up our homes.

I guarantee this will be a fun surprise when your kids go to get their silverware in order to eat breakfast in the morning and find the elves new hiding places.

Make sure to leave the actual silverware somewhere accessible, or use this as an opportunity to use plastic for a day.